Harmful Mental Effects of Television Viewing
"We now have evidence that habitual viewing (of television) can affect a young person's basic outlook and sensibilities, predisposition to violence and hyperactivity, IQ, reading ability, imagination, play, language patterns, critical thinking, self-image, perception of others, and values in general." (Rivers)
(adbusters)Constant television viewing can be harmful to a person’s social and intellectual development. Various child development and educational experts agree that children nowadays who are watching an excess of television viewing are not developing the way they should. This can be attributed to television’s numbing effect on the brain. Television hinders the development of language, creativity, and reading skills in people. Television viewing is especially harmful to young minds developing these skills.
Television viewing tends to prolong dominance of right brain functions, and thus causes a trance-like state of mind. When television viewing exceeds twenty hours in one week, the left hemisphere of the brain experiences serious problems developing verbal-logical functions. Word knowledge and vocabulary are not affected in either a positive or negative way by television viewing, yet creative verbal fluency is much lower for active television viewers than for people who abstain from television. (Summary) "There is a direct correlation between the amount of time a child spends watching TV and their scores on standardized achievement tests - the more TV watched, the lower the scores" (Hardebeck).
"There are more videotape stores than book stores in the U.S. today" (Mander). Television viewing requires little concentration and less thinking than reading does. While reading a book trains people to have longer attention spans, television viewing does just the opposite. When watching television the brain activities switch from beta waves (indicating alert consciousness) to alpha waves (indicating lower consciousness). Certain electronic impulses occur in the brain while watching television which do not normally occur when the eyes are open. These impulses keep the eye in one place for an extended period of time, as well as focused in a manner that is normally unnatural. These side effects are harmful, especially to young children who are just learning to read because they train skills that are the opposite of what reading demands. With extended television viewing, reading books becomes more difficult. (Mander)
(Hardebeck)Television viewing is particularly damaging to a person's sense of wonder and imagination. During imaginative play, people actively experience the real world and new experiences on their own. When watching television, viewers become passive recipients of experience and are dictated experiences which they have no control over. This is often a reversal of ordinary life, because during imaginative play children have complete control, and can act out any role they desire. In a sense, television leaves no way for the viewer to issue any sort of imaginative control over the outcome of the program. Eventually people become dependent on outside sources to create images, and ideas because a large part of their thinking is filled up with television. (Rivers)
Television often gives people a view of a fast-paced and exciting world which is very unrealistic. This can be damaging to people's real world experiences that cannot possibly compete with the world of television actors. People’s real life experiences are thereby seen as less than perfectand can lead to such mental conditions such as low self-esteem, and depression. Actors on television are often seen as role models for attitudes and actions. People see characters resolve problems easily, and are confused why real life problems are so complicated and take longer than thirty minutes to solve. In this way, television also gives viewers a distorted view the world around them, as well as the people around them. (Winn)
Economic Effects on Television Viewers
"Television, because of its ability to illustrate and dramatize an advertiser's message is the most powerful medium for sales stimulation" (Adler)
(Adbusters)One of the first uses for television was to make money. Advertisers use the fact that they can portray their product into millions of potential consumer’s homes, by giving massive amounts of money to television studios in trade for time on their broadcasts. Television advertising started out in a similar manner to that of radio advertising. However, as the new medium of television became more understood, advertisers started to redefine the way they sold their products. Television allows the advertiser to show consumers their products in a purely positive manner. Older mediums such as radio or print never had the amount of influence television has, and in this way advertisers can sell their products to consumers by the millions, and with a new power of influence. (Alder) If it were not for television’s tremendous power to influence people, television would not be as popular as it is today.
"Television is promoting a lifestyle. It is a virtual reality that advertisers and networksseek to promote in order to gain additional revenue" (Mander). Television advertisements promote a lifestyle that is not natural, and is promoting a consumer oriented society. Television creates a world that is product-oriented; the viewers watching this world mentally connect to the actors on the screen because of small similarities. This is how advertising changes the way in which people think, and interact with others in their society. (Mander)
Television advertising has the power to put a single message or idea into millions of people’s minds at the same time. A powerful ad shown at the right time can influence a large number of citizens in as much as a majority of the world owns, and watches television. Most of the advertisements on television promote commercialism, and buying processed products. With its combination of massive distribution and powerful messages, television is one of the most influential tools in the modern world and it is being used to create a materialistic society.
(adbusters)Works Cited
Adbusters (http://www.adbusters.org/Media/welcome.html) Mar 21, 1998.
Brook & Boal. Resisting the Virtual Life. City Lights: San Francisco, 1995.
Hardebeck, Daniel J. The Kill Your Television Website. (http://othello.localaccess.com/hardebeck/) Feb 23, 1998.
Electronic Heroin. (http://dieoff.org/page21.htm) Feb 26, 1998.
Fat Wreck Chords. Fat Wreck Chords Presents Survival of the Fattest. San Francisco, 1998.
Jerry, Mander. Review of Jerry Mander’s Four Arguments For the Elimination of Television. (http://www.netreach.net/people/kaufman/Jerry.Mander.html) Feb 21, 1998.
Rivers, Karen. Human Values and the Effects of Television on Children. Feb 26, 1998.Summary of Research on the Effects of Television Viewing. (http://netletter.com/GMWS/unTV/research.htm) Feb 20,1998.
Winn, Marie. The Plug-In Drug. New York: Viking. 1977
Links to other television related sites
The Kill Your TV Website Created by Daniel Hardebeck and filled with information and links to other television sites.
Television Free America Filled with information about turn off TV week, and things to do instead of watching TV.
Adbusters Culture Jammers Headquarters
Electronic Heroin An essay comparing television to an addicting drug.
Summary of Research on the effects of Television Viewing
This Web site is incomplete. There is much more information out there on the side-effects of television viewing, however time consrtaints restrict me. For more information or comments send e-mail to Paulsk@mala.bc.ca